>> I read somewhere that I can increase the memory on my iBook G4 which has
>> suddenly become slow as treacle. I have tried verifying permissions and
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> even a slow computer. it sounds like there may be a hardware issue,
> perhaps a failing hard drive.
Oh not again!! This will be my eighth 2.5 inch hard drive to go in about
three years on eight different computers, most with the same symptoms. But I
had just assumed that the reports on the drive on DiskUtility along with the
SMART report were sufficient.
And I had assumed that as only one of them was on a Mac (a Powerbook G4),
they were somehow more reliable than PC drives.
This is one of thoseMacs in which you have to take virutually the whole
drive apart to get to the drive, isnt it?
As to Leopard, does it run properly once it is installed if I buy a gig of
PC2100 memory? (I was sure I had read on the Apple site that you cant put
any more than 640 MG in it)
news.rcn.com - 29 May 2008 14:00 GMT
> Oh not again!! This will be my eighth 2.5 inch hard drive to go in about
> three years on eight different computers, most with the same symptoms. But
> I had just assumed that the reports on the drive on DiskUtility along with
> the SMART report were sufficient.
>
> And I had assumed that as only one of them was on a Mac (a Powerbook G4),
Oh and can I poll opinions on whether it is worthwhile paying as much as a
couple of second hand hard drives for Disk Warrior please?
nospam - 29 May 2008 14:36 GMT
> Oh and can I poll opinions on whether it is worthwhile paying as much as a
> couple of second hand hard drives for Disk Warrior please?
diskwarrior is worth its weight in gold, but it won't fix a mechanical
problem with a drive.
Martin Trautmann - 29 May 2008 14:06 GMT
> This is one of thoseMacs in which you have to take virutually the whole
> drive apart to get to the drive, isnt it?
perfectly true - but taking the docu from ifixit it was mainly time, but
not that difficult.
I had to open the laptop anyway since it caught the famous C-clamp
soldering failure.
> As to Leopard, does it run properly once it is installed if I buy a gig of
> PC2100 memory? (I was sure I had read on the Apple site that you cant put
> any more than 640 MG in it)
This was an early limit, which never was true, since the PB 12" was
released earlier and could handle 1 GB SDRAM.
However. later docu increased the 512 MB limit up to 1 GB.
- Martin
nospam - 29 May 2008 14:36 GMT
> Oh not again!! This will be my eighth 2.5 inch hard drive to go in about
> three years on eight different computers, most with the same symptoms. But I
> had just assumed that the reports on the drive on DiskUtility along with the
> SMART report were sufficient.
if smart says the drive is bad, it's bad. if smart doesn't say it's
bad, the drive might be dying or it might be fine. so just because you
are getting positive reports doesn't mean that a problem isn't lurking
within.
> And I had assumed that as only one of them was on a Mac (a Powerbook G4),
> they were somehow more reliable than PC drives.
the same drives are used in both macs and pcs.
> This is one of thoseMacs in which you have to take virutually the whole
> drive apart to get to the drive, isnt it?
ibooks are a *bitch* to swap hard drives.
> As to Leopard, does it run properly once it is installed if I buy a gig of
> PC2100 memory? (I was sure I had read on the Apple site that you cant put
> any more than 640 MG in it)
g3 ibooks were limited to 640 meg. g4 ibooks can take more.
news.rcn.com - 29 May 2008 16:51 GMT
>> Oh not again!! This will be my eighth 2.5 inch hard drive to go in about
>> three years on eight different computers, most with the same symptoms.
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
> are getting positive reports doesn't mean that a problem isn't lurking
> within.
Is it still the case that you cant boot from a Drive Fitness Testing cd with
a Mac and test the drive? Or CAN you boot from UBCD4WIN just to check the
drive? Or Ubuntu if there is some drive testing utility in it?
>> And I had assumed that as only one of them was on a Mac (a Powerbook G4),
>> they were somehow more reliable than PC drives.
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
>
> g3 ibooks were limited to 640 meg. g4 ibooks can take more.
Rob McCleave - 29 May 2008 17:54 GMT
> Is it still the case that you cant boot from a Drive Fitness Testing cd with
> a Mac and test the drive? Or CAN you boot from UBCD4WIN just to check the
> drive? Or Ubuntu if there is some drive testing utility in it?
If Drive Fitness Testing and UBCD4WIN are written for a PC, they won't
boot any kind of Mac with a Power PC G4 chip in it. A Linux CD written
for PPC chip should boot it.
The install CD that came with the iBook will definitely boot the machine
and you can run the disk utility from the CD and get the (admittedly
limited) diagnostics and repair functions that it provides.
Apart from out and out failure there is also the possibility that the
drive is close to full. That will make the computer slower and less
reliable.
If that is the case, new drives are cheap, but of course replacement of
a full drive is as much pain as replacing a failed drive. I see tiny
Torx head screws rolling off the table...
news.rcn.com - 29 May 2008 21:58 GMT
>> Is it still the case that you cant boot from a Drive Fitness Testing cd
>> with
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> and you can run the disk utility from the CD and get the (admittedly
> limited) diagnostics and repair functions that it provides.
Things dont look all that good: Though the drive has Tiger installed on it,
I used original install discs. I selected repair on the Fujitsu drive
itself and it told me in red that 15 reserve fields in the catalogue count
have incorrect data and that there is an invalid leaf count (It should be 16
instead of 18)
It then said the iBook G4 (HFS) drive was repaired successfully AND that it
tried to repair 2 volumes (presumably the other being the Fujitsu drive?)
and that the other volume could not be repaired.
On Verify Permissions, All sorts of verifications come up wrong and
ultimately I get a 'DISK UTILITY INTERNAL ERROR D. U. has lost its
connection with Disk management Tool and cannot continue, please quit and
relaunch disk utility'. then it announces that if you quit you may destroy
your OS. It then does go into 'repair permissions' and I get the same get
a 'DISK UTILITY INTERNAL ERROR D. U. has lost its connection with Disk
management Tool and cannot continue, please quit and relaunch disk utility'
with lots of suspicious sounding clicking at aroud 80% complete. Running
verification again passes the verifications which were repaired but
ominously starts the clicking at the same place again. I wonder if this
means trouble with the platters! Something SMART couldnt repair with
replacing bad sectors with spare ones?
Anyway re-running Disk Repair gives invalid leaf record count and the HFS
Vol is OK, the other one could not be repaired again.
> Apart from out and out failure there is also the possibility that the
> drive is close to full. That will make the computer slower and less
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> a full drive is as much pain as replacing a failed drive. I see tiny
> Torx head screws rolling off the table...