
Signature
(Preferably reply to the newsgroup, please. If you reply by Email, I
will sincerely try to receive your message, but it will probably get
buried in spam.)
> A long time ago, I had a 16MHz 68030 PowerBook, with a very short
> battery life, so I had a lot of batteries. To make that situation more
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>
> Do any of you know of any gizmo of this sort for the 17" PowerBooks?
it is not needed - you can sleep and swap the battery in nearly every
version of the powerbook, including the powerbook 17".
this gizmo was only needed for the first version of the powerbooks, the
100, 140 & 170. subsequent powerbooks had an internal battery to
maintain it during sleep.
the ibook was the first apple laptop that lacked this battery, and
later, the powerbook 12", which is essentially an ibook.
all other powerbooks, including the 17" can swap batteries during sleep.
Gary Morrison - 31 Jul 2005 23:03 GMT
> it is not needed - you can sleep and swap the battery in nearly every
> version of the powerbook, including the powerbook 17".
Well now, that's strange: I coulda sworn I'd tried that before on this
PowerBook, expecting it to behave as you described, only to see the
sleep light flicker off immediately upon removing the battery.
However, I just now tried it and yes, it did indeed work. Perhaps
something weird just happened to go wrong that one time I tried it, or
maybe my 40-some-odd-year-old memory is what's "flickering off."

Signature
(Preferably reply to the newsgroup, please. If you reply by Email, I
will sincerely try to receive your message, but it will probably get
buried in spam.)
pailface88@yahoo.com - 01 Aug 2005 00:22 GMT
Gary, your PRAM battery can indeed be bad. They only last a few years.
On some models they were a nicad or NiMH and on some models they were
Li-Ion, all rechargable, but they do have a finite lifespan. On many of
the older powerbooks the PRAM battery was supposed to be able to keep
the computer RAM contents alive for 4 minutes while changing out the
main battery. As the PRAM battery aged, this time would be reduced
eventually to zero, while the PRAM battery still had enough capacity to
actually keep PRAM contents alive while the computer was turned OFF
(shut down) and while the AC power and main battery were both removed.
Therefore, just because your computer keeps its date and time when no
AC or battery power is being supplied to it does not mean that your
PRAM battery is good enough to keep the RAM alive while swapping out
the main battery in Sleep mode.
pailface88@yahoo.com - 31 Jul 2005 23:07 GMT
> the ibook was the first apple laptop that lacked this battery, and
later, the powerbook 12", which is essentially an ibook.
It should be noted that even though the ibook lacks a PRAM battery, it
can still have the main battery swapped while in Sleep mode. It has a
large value capacitor to do the same jop as a PRAM battery in this
respect.