I have just been advised by my computer that the external disc which I
used for my Time machine back-ups is nearly full - I've been using
200Gb external disc since last November with the default settings, so
it's done quite well.
The warning tells me that Time Machine will start to delete the oldest
data on the back-up disc so my question is this...
If I have not looked at a file - document, photo etc - since last
November, will it now no longer be available via Time Machine?
My thinking is that the document/photo would have been backed up to
the external drive last November but there would be no incremental
back-up since because there has been no change to the file. Or s Time
Machine cleverer than I'm giving it credit for?
Thanks...
Jay
Frédérique & Her vé Sainct - 25 May 2008 10:12 GMT
> The warning tells me that Time Machine will start to delete the oldest
> data on the back-up disc so my question is this...
> If I have not looked at a file - document, photo etc - since last
> November, will it now no longer be available via Time Machine?
If you have *deleted* a file in November on your mac, and wish to get it
back now (assuming TM needs to delete "everything November"), then you
will have lost it.
If you have left it on your mac, or deleted only later, then TM will
keep it.
Basically, the technical way TM deals with backups is a bit complex
(dated folders with hard links pointing on a single file when no change,
to save space) but seen from us, the end-users, the result is as if TM
kept regularly separate backup copies of your data.
Then when it deletes "November data", everything that was present in
your mac *after November*, e. g. in December, is still there. (in the
"december" folder)

Signature
Frédérique & Hervé Sainct, h.sainct@laposte.net [fr,es,en,it]
Frédérique's initial is missing in front of the above address
l'initiale de Frédérique manque devant l'adresse email ci-dessus
Chris Ridd - 25 May 2008 10:22 GMT
> I have just been advised by my computer that the external disc which I
> used for my Time machine back-ups is nearly full - I've been using
> 200Gb external disc since last November with the default settings, so
> it's done quite well.
If you want to buy a bigger disk for use with TM, you will need to use
SuperDuper! to clone the old TM disk across to it. Lesser tools (eg
Finder) will not work correctly.
> The warning tells me that Time Machine will start to delete the oldest
> data on the back-up disc so my question is this...
> If I have not looked at a file - document, photo etc - since last
> November, will it now no longer be available via Time Machine?
It'll still be there.
> My thinking is that the document/photo would have been backed up to
> the external drive last November but there would be no incremental
> back-up since because there has been no change to the file. Or s Time
> Machine cleverer than I'm giving it credit for?
It is cleverer.
Cheers,
Chris
Frédérique & Her vé Sainct - 25 May 2008 14:50 GMT
> If you want to buy a bigger disk for use with TM, you will need to use
> SuperDuper! to clone the old TM disk across to it. Lesser tools (eg
> Finder) will not work correctly.
or a terminal command with sudo that'd respect the file ownerships

Signature
Frédérique & Hervé Sainct, h.sainct@laposte.net [fr,es,en,it]
Frédérique's initial is missing in front of the above address
l'initiale de Frédérique manque devant l'adresse email ci-dessus
Chris Ridd - 25 May 2008 15:08 GMT
On 2008-05-25 14:50:29 +0100, h.sainct@laposte.net.invalid (Frédérique
& Hervé Sainct) said:
>> If you want to buy a bigger disk for use with TM, you will need to use
>> SuperDuper! to clone the old TM disk across to it. Lesser tools (eg
>> Finder) will not work correctly.
>
> or a terminal command with sudo that'd respect the file ownerships
I wouldn't bother wasting time trying to find stuff that preserves
stuff like ACLs, and more importantly can handle hard-linked
directories. SuperDuper! works, in free mode.
Cheers,
Chris
Simon Slavin - 27 May 2008 22:24 GMT
On 25/05/2008, Jay wrote in message <c3c244f7-1885-4326-ad39-
955ef57e0d98@c65g2000hsa.googlegroups.com>:
> The warning tells me that Time Machine will start to delete the oldest
> data on the back-up disc so my question is this...
> If I have not looked at a file - document, photo etc - since last
> November, will it now no longer be available via Time Machine?
It first deletes files which have multiple, oldest copies. The only way
it can delete every copy of one of your files is for your Time Machine
partition to be smaller than the partition it's backing up.
Simon.

Signature
http://www.hearsay.demon.co.uk
David - 31 May 2008 14:08 GMT
> My thinking is that the document/photo would have been backed up to
> the external drive last November but there would be no incremental
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
> Jay
It deletes the old backup. If you check the Time Machine drive you will
find something like "latest" and when you go to that folder it is the
most up to date back of ALL your stuff. I have a 500GB drive and the
latest backup is 300GB yet if I go to a folder dated a month ago it too
appears to be 300GB Time machine appears to be very smart :)

Signature
David
DigMo!
Main RSS : http://www.digmo.co.uk/feed
Moving Image RSS :http://www.digmo.co.uk/category/mia/feed
Music RSS : http://www.digmo.co.uk/category/music/feed