>>>> A new Safari-specific vulnerability (which appears to affect
>>>> Mail.app as well) has been documented by the German site
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> security problems. Just switching a browser is no substitute for the
> user being intelligent.
That's the crux of it! Unfortunately, this kind of thing is along the same
lines a confidence tricking. Intelligent people also have their limits.
In this circumstance, Apple have already posted their advice on the matter
when it was found that an executable could be put into a file purporting to
be an MP3. They recommended turning off the automatically open "safe"
downloads. That was a good couple of years ago, so this really should not be
anything new. Personally, I think there is no such thing as a safe download.
Any downloaded file should be looked at carefully.
J.J. O'Shea - 22 Feb 2006 03:17 GMT
>>>>> A new Safari-specific vulnerability (which appears to affect
>>>>> Mail.app as well) has been documented by the German site
[quoted text clipped - 25 lines]
> anything new. Personally, I think there is no such thing as a safe download.
> Any downloaded file should be looked at carefully.
Personally, I turned it off mostly because that was the fastest way to get
rid of the warning message that would pop up *each and every time* I
downloaded something which might auto-open. Opening the files myself was less
annoying than putting up with that message. More secure, too, but the
annoyance factor was definitely the major factor.
That was then, when there were no real malware on the loose for OS X. Now
that there actually is malware, even though they're _stupid_ malware which
are easily defanged, the security aspect is #1.
Meanwhile, over on my Windows box, I had to have multiple 'security' apps
running, which sucked down performance till my 2.83GHz Pentium 4 with 1.25GB
RAM was slower at many tasks than my 1.25GHz eMac with 1GB RAM. Just booting
the bloody thing up takes forever. (Well, okay, just over three minutes from
POST beep to no more hourglass; the same machine boots Linux to the desktop
in under 45 seconds, so it ain't the hardware...)

Signature
email to oshea dot j dot j at gmail dot com.
Daniel Cohen - 22 Feb 2006 10:30 GMT
> In this circumstance, Apple have already posted their advice on the matter
> when it was found that an executable could be put into a file purporting to
> be an MP3. They recommended turning off the automatically open "safe"
> downloads. That was a good couple of years ago, so this really should not be
> anything new. Personally, I think there is no such thing as a safe download.
> Any downloaded file should be looked at carefully.
As you say, the advice is not new.
But with the previous exploit, Apple soon provided a security update
that solved the problem even if "safe" downloads were opened
automatically., so many of us went back to this convenient choice. I
hope they will be able to do so this time.

Signature
Send e-mail to the Reply-To address;
mail to the From address is never read
Paul Halliday - 22 Feb 2006 20:07 GMT
>> In this circumstance, Apple have already posted their advice on the matter
>> when it was found that an executable could be put into a file purporting to
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> automatically., so many of us went back to this convenient choice. I
> hope they will be able to do so this time.
Indeed! As a, well, not too recent switcher, I've always been very impressed
with the speed at which Apple have dealt with security issues. Timely and
well documented. I'm sure we'll see a Security Update in a short while.
> >>> A new Safari-specific vulnerability (which appears to affect
> >>> Mail.app as well) has been documented by the German site
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> security problems. Just switching a browser is no substitute for the
> user being intelligent.
Nor is turning off a web browser preference if you manually download a
piece of malware and execute it. The best way to guard against being
harmed by malware is to think before you do things.