I have a PC at work and a PowerBook at home.
I have been using Thunderbird on my PC and Mail on my mac, but have had
some serious problems with the combination.
It seems that messages deleted (read: sent to trash) with Mail are
expunged (read: deleted forever) by Thunderbird when it tries to load
your trash folder.
This is a big problem for me, as I keep my mail in the trash folder
until I archive it. I've lost a lot of messages with the combo, and
have since stopped using Thunderbird.
Any suggestions? Does mail mark IMAP messages differently? Does this
sound like a Thunderbird or a Mail problem?
Thanks,
Ben P.
Booker C. Bense - 12 Jan 2005 21:26 GMT
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
>I have a PC at work and a PowerBook at home.
>
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>until I archive it. I've lost a lot of messages with the combo, and
>have since stopped using Thunderbird.
_ You might try just using Thunderbird on both. I've been using
Thunderbird on my mac and while a bit slower than Mail, it works
in a very similar way and there's nothing I've found that is
missing.
>Any suggestions? Does mail mark IMAP messages differently? Does this
>sound like a Thunderbird or a Mail problem?
_ My guess is some weird interaction between the two with neither
being the "problem". You might look into the various preferences
to see if there is a time out on the Trash folder. My guess is
that "delete after X-days" is likely implemented by some special
header and one or the other is looking for something that's not
there.
Putting things you want to potentially archive in "Trash" is
bending the intent of the interface, but that's a wholely
different problem.
_ Booker C. Bense
David C. - 13 Jan 2005 03:40 GMT
> I have been using Thunderbird on my PC and Mail on my mac, but have
> had some serious problems with the combination.
>
> It seems that messages deleted (read: sent to trash) with Mail are
> expunged (read: deleted forever) by Thunderbird when it tries to load
> your trash folder.
This is an IMAP preference you can configure.
Go to Tools->Account Settings on the menu bar. Then go to the "Server
Settings" page for your IMAP account.
There are two checkboxes you will want to tweak:
Clean up ("Expunge") Inbox on Exit
Empty Trash on Exit
> This is a big problem for me, as I keep my mail in the trash folder
> until I archive it. I've lost a lot of messages with the combo, and
> have since stopped using Thunderbird.
IMO, this is a bad practice in general. If you want to archive
messages, use some folder other than the Trash. Trash means (to most
people and most programs) that you want to be rid of the contents.
-- David
manthrax3@gmail.com - 13 Jan 2005 14:54 GMT
> IMO, this is a bad practice in general. If you want to archive
> messages, use some folder other than the Trash. Trash means (to most
> people and most programs) that you want to be rid of the contents.
I agree, but it's convenient because I can hit [delete] and a message
goes out of my inbox immediately.
I like the "Archive" button in GMail, and I'd love to see a similar
button on most thick client apps.
bp
oliver - 10 Mar 2005 22:13 GMT
have a look at the preferences of both of your applications. it's the app
which decides how to trash.
olli
>I have a PC at work and a PowerBook at home.
>
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> Thanks,
> Ben P.