I have an original 2x dual-core Mac Pro. I've found that the only
thing I can do to stress the cores is Handbrake encoding, in pretty
much every other case the majority of cores are idled.
I'd like to try to keep about the same performance, but lower my power
use. I'm wondering if I can do this with the new Xeons, the Penryn
series?
The first question is obvious: are there drop-in replacements? I
assume that due to the lower power and thermal loads, non-logical
backplane support will not be an issue.
I seem to recall that the Mac Pro can run with one CPU removed... but
what are the performance differences inherent in 1 four-core CPU as
opposed to 2 dual-core ones? If these differences are limited to
certain workloads, this might be something I'd consider.
So, any Xeon experts out there?
Maury
> I have an original 2x dual-core Mac Pro. I've found that the only
> thing I can do to stress the cores is Handbrake encoding, in pretty
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
>
> Maury
Not a XEON expert myself, though I've had opportunities to "play" a
bit with Pentium-II-XEON workstations and Pentium-III-XEON servers, I
haven't owned my own (i.e., "since it's mine I can just plain screw
with it until something dies"--my usual personal computer m.o. when I
don't depend on it for my livelihood). On the other hand, Anand Lal
Shimpi of Anandtech wrote this article, http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=2832
, which offers useful insight to DYI upgrading of a Mac Pro from its
original configuration (one of the first) to running lots of RAM, more
hard drives, and-oh, yes-a pair of Intel pre-production prototypes of
the Quad-Core XEON. His step-by-step illustrated guide and written
warnings in the text appear pretty useful info to anyone upgrading one
of these beasties.
Oh, by the way, Anand also includes info pertinent to some of your
questions about performance... you may want to look at Anandtech's
guides/reviews to/of Penryn CPU's and Intel's development path, too.
Best wishes!
PumpkinEscobar - 16 Nov 2007 12:47 GMT
> > I have an original 2x dual-core Mac Pro. I've found that the only
> > thing I can do to stress the cores is Handbrake encoding, in pretty
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
> >
> > Maury
Don't know about Penryns, but the 4-Core chips will drop in, turning
your Mac Prp into a 6 or 8 cormachine depending on how many you replace.
--