I'm not an expert, but my weak detective skills tell me that "Evaluate"
is a VBA function, so the referenced workbook is cheating, so to speak.
You can do most anything you want with macro tools.
And given the little oddity :-) with Office 2008, that ChtFrmla file
isn't going to be much good for a while.
> ronbar -
>
[quoted text clipped - 22 lines]
> >
> > cheers

Signature
Team EM to the rescue! http://www.team-em.com
Mike Middleton - 14 Mar 2008 23:38 GMT
Carl Witthoft -
"Evaluate" is an Excel VBA method, but EVALUATE is also an Excel 4 XLM macro
function.
Generally, Excel 4 XLM macro functions can be used as "refers to" for
defined names, which is the approach Stephen Bullen used in ChtFrmla.xls.
And all versions of Excel since Excel 4, Windows and Mac, support Excel 4
XLM code.
The original poster did not specify which version of Excel he is using.
My limited testing indicates that Stephen Bullen's ChtFrmla.xls (which was
saved as an Excel 5.0/95 workbook) works fine in Windows Excel 97 and 2008
and in Mac Excel 2004. So far I haven't gotten it to work in Windows Excel
2003 or in Mac Excel 2008.
- Mike Middleton
http://www.DecisionToolworks.com
Decision Analysis Add-ins for Excel
> I'm not an expert, but my weak detective skills tell me that "Evaluate"
> is a VBA function, so the referenced workbook is cheating, so to speak.
[quoted text clipped - 32 lines]
>> >
>> > cheers
Carl Witthoft - 15 Mar 2008 15:25 GMT
Interesting. Thanks for the pointer. Given the results of your
testing, it appears Bullen used VBA to build his function. I suppose
one could rewrite it using XLM macro .
> Carl Witthoft -
>
[quoted text clipped - 44 lines]
> >> http://www.DecisionToolworks.com
> >> Decision Analysis Add-ins for Excel

Signature
Team EM to the rescue! http://www.team-em.com
Mike Middleton - 15 Mar 2008 19:22 GMT
Carl Witthoft -
There is no VBA code in Stephen Bullen's ChtFrmla.xls workbook.
The only slightly-nonstandard portion is the Excel 4 XLM macro function
EVALUATE in the defined name y.
I don't know why I can't get it to work on Windows Excel 2003 and Mac Excel
2008.
- Mike Middleton
> Interesting. Thanks for the pointer. Given the results of your
> testing, it appears Bullen used VBA to build his function. I suppose
[quoted text clipped - 54 lines]
>> >> http://www.DecisionToolworks.com
>> >> Decision Analysis Add-ins for Excel