Hi,
(I realise MW Ron has now left the building, so there maybe nobody else
qualified to answer this, plus codewarrior.windows is a tad quiet now...)
Considering Codewarrior for Windows (v9, running on Mac OS X) is not for
sale anymore, what is the situation with licenses?
Our customer will eventually receive the source code for one our projects
whereupon they will continue maintenance of the software. We still need all
our licenses, so what must our customer do? We don't have any spare and I
have been unable to find a copy for sale?
Because this is now obsolete software do the license terms still apply? (I'm
no expert here!)
Thanks for any advice.

Signature
Regards,
Steve
"...which means he created the heaven and the earth... in the DARK! How good
is that?"
brandon - 19 Jan 2006 07:28 GMT
you should be able to transition your windows code to VC++ without
much fuss. you're also assured an upgrade path that way, and it'll
probably be cheaper since you can use the VC++ compiler for free.
Steve - 26 Jan 2006 20:58 GMT
On 19/1/06 07:28, in article
1137655707.712513.60260@g14g2000cwa.googlegroups.com, "brandon"
<bsneed@gmail.com> wrote:
> you should be able to transition your windows code to VC++ without
> much fuss. you're also assured an upgrade path that way, and it'll
> probably be cheaper since you can use the VC++ compiler for free.
Probably, but if our customer isn't willing to pay for the work, we're not
going to do the work for free!

Signature
Regards,
Steve
"...which means he created the heaven and the earth... in the DARK! How good
is that?"
brandon - 26 Jan 2006 21:40 GMT
That is completely understandable.
larry@skytag.com - 19 Jan 2006 08:34 GMT
I have absolutely no clue what the legal status is, but you could try
contacting Freescale to see what they say. Someone there might even
remember the product. ;-) Other solutions include:
- Don't worry about it. Freescale isn't going to be hunting down people
who are using a copy they didn't purchase.
- Check around for a used copy. More and more people will have a copy
they don't use anymore and would probably be willing to sell.
Larry
Jonathan Hoyle - 25 Jan 2006 19:07 GMT
>> Considering Codewarrior for Windows (v9, running on Mac OS X) is
>> not for sale anymore, what is the situation with licenses?
Legally speaking (unfortunately), the license still applies, despite
the fact the product has been discontinued with no replacement (I've
often wondered how much more productive things would be if discontinued
products essentially became "freeware").
However, there are a number of options available to you. Firstly, I
still see CodeWarrior 9 available on Ebay, so that is a way to get the
product. Secondly, CodeWarrior 10 is similar enough to 9 that you may
be able to modify the project only slight to compile under 10. That
way, your customers can download CodeWarrior 10 for only $99 and
compile the project. Finally, you may have to simply back away from
supporting this project. After all, if your project is using
unsupported tools to build, you are left in the unenviable position to
do the supporting.
Upgrading your project to CodeWarrior 10 seems like the best approach
to me.
Jonathan Hoyle
Eastman Kodak
brandon - 25 Jan 2006 19:34 GMT
his customers would have to obtain components from 9 to make it build
windows apps, and even then they would be without debugging
capabilities.
Jonathan Hoyle - 25 Jan 2006 19:57 GMT
>> his customers would have to obtain components from 9 to
>> make it build windows apps, and even then they would be
>> without debugging capabilities.
Ah, Windows compatibility is required. (I didn't catch that the first
time.) In that case, he may have no choice but to purchase a copy of
CW 9 second hand. (I do not believe that the CW 9 Win compiler plugin
works in the CW 10 IDE, as the project types have changed from 9 to
10.) You can still find it at places. Ecost sells the Windows version
for an outrageous $539.94:
http://www.ecost.com/ecost/shop/detail.asp?dpno=553524 ; hopefully you
can find it cheaper, but there you have it. The Mac OS X version can
be gotten for as little as $185.99 at
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=5851698544 .
Someone may be able to weasel you a copy, but that would not be a
viable recommendation for your customers.
Regards,
Jonathan Hoyle
Eastman Kodak
James W. Walker - 26 Jan 2006 07:34 GMT
> (I do not believe that the CW 9 Win compiler plugin
> works in the CW 10 IDE, as the project types have changed from 9 to
> 10.)
The CW 9 WIndows parts do work in the CW 10 IDE, with a couple of
exceptions:
1. You probably need to use the CW 9 version of MSL for Windows, since
its Windows-specific parts were not updated for CW 10.
2. Remote debugging does not work with a Windows target.
Jonathan Hoyle - 26 Jan 2006 22:14 GMT
>> The CW 9 WIndows parts do work in the CW 10 IDE, with a
>> couple of exceptions:
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>>
>> 2. Remote debugging does not work with a Windows target.
That's excellent to hear. I currently have two versions of CodeWarrior
on my portable, 9 and 10, one for cross-platform work, and one for
Mac-only. I sounds like I can combine them into one.
Is there a procedure you can recommend to me for combining. I assume I
start with the CW 10 folder and begin dragging certain items from the
CW 9 folder for the Windows stuff. Or perhaps it is better to begin
with the CW9 Mac/Win directory, and add the CW 10 Mac items?
Thanks in advance,
Jonathan Hoyle
brandon - 27 Jan 2006 01:17 GMT
Well, the time i tried, i basically went through v9 directory and any
files that 10 didn't have, i copied.
I also had to paste the windows portions of my v9 license into the v10
license file.
There are some changes to a few of the v10 MSL headers that don't
compile with the v9 window compiler, but they're pretty straight
forward to fix.
The whole operation took less than an hour, and a good portion of that
was spent trying in vain to get the v9 debugger plugin to work without
making a stub to shim from the v9 plugin format to the v10 format.